Audio Mixers for Church Livestreaming
When your church livestream includes a full worship team—vocals, drums, and multiple instruments—your audio mixer becomes the command center for both in-room and streaming sound. With so many options available, it can feel overwhelming to choose. To make things easier, here are four reliable audio mixers for church livestreaming, two analog and two digital, that offer excellent value and features to help you get started.
Analog vs Digital: What’s the Difference?
Analog mixers use physical circuits and controls—each knob or fader changes the sound directly. They’re easy for volunteers to understand, cost less upfront, and are ideal for smaller or traditional setups.
Digital mixers, meanwhile, convert sound into digital signals, allowing advanced processing, presets, and remote control. They can save time before services and allow for consistent sound week to week.
Both can sound fantastic—the right choice depends on your budget, volunteer experience, and how complex your setup is.
Analog Mixers: Simple and Reliable
Behringer X2222USB
A Budget-Friendly Starting Point
The Behringer X2222USB offers 22 inputs, 8 mic preamps, built-in compressors, and a USB interface for easy recording or streaming. It’s affordable, intuitive, and ideal for smaller worship spaces or youth ministries where volunteers need something simple and dependable.
Why it works well for churches:
- Easy for volunteers to understand
- Built-in USB output for streaming or recording
- Onboard effects for vocals or instruments
Mackie Onyx 24
A Solid Step-Up Analog Option
For churches wanting higher-quality sound and more flexibility, the Mackie Onyx 24 delivers. With 24 inputs and Mackie’s respected Onyx mic preamps, it provides clean headroom and rich tone. It also includes a USB multitrack interface, allowing you to record every channel directly to a computer—perfect for post-service mixing or podcast editing.
Why it’s a strong choice:
- 24 premium Onyx preamps with 4-band EQ
- Multitrack USB recording built-in
- Sturdy build made for long-term use
Digital Mixers: Powerful and Future-Ready
Behringer X32 Compact
A Proven Digital Workhorse
The Behringer X32 Compact continues to be one of the most-used church mixers in the world. It supports up to 40 channels (16 onboard plus expansion via stage box), full scene recall, and tablet-based remote control through the X32-Mix app. Volunteers can mix from anywhere in the sanctuary or even from the stage.
Why it’s volunteer-friendly:
- Tablet control makes setup flexible
- Presets and scenes save service settings
- Affordable entry point into digital mixing
PreSonus StudioLive 32S
Professional Performance in a Church Setting
The PreSonus StudioLive 32S offers 32 inputs and is ideal for churches ready to scale up. Each channel includes full Fat Channel processing (EQ, compression, gate), and the mixer can record multitrack audio directly to Studio One or an SD card. It’s also network-ready with AVB, allowing expansion for future growth.
Why it stands out:
- Seamless mixing and recording in one unit
- App control for personal monitor mixes
- Scene recall simplifies Sunday setup
Analog vs Digital at a Glance
| Feature | Analog Mixers | Digital Mixers |
|---|---|---|
| Ease of Use | Very simple for volunteers | Slight learning curve, but powerful |
| Scene Recall | No | Yes |
| Built-in Effects | Basic | Extensive options |
| Recording | Usually stereo USB | Multitrack recording |
| Price Range | Lower upfront | Higher, but longer lifespan |
| Great For | Small to mid-size setups | Growing, multi-room, or streaming campuses |
How to Choose the Right Mixer for Your Church
- Count your inputs. Include every mic, instrument, and playback source—and plan 20% headroom for growth.
- Consider your volunteers. Analog mixers are easier to learn, while digital mixers reward teams willing to invest time learning presets and layers.
- Plan for streaming. Look for mixers with USB or network outputs so your livestream feed can be mixed separately from your sanctuary sound.
- Think long-term. A solid digital mixer may cost more upfront but can serve your church for many years with firmware updates and expandable I/O.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right audio mixer is about finding what fits your volunteers and your church’s vision—not just what’s “best.” The four options above—from the hands-on simplicity of Behringer and Mackie to the digital flexibility of PreSonus and Behringer’s X32—cover a wide range of needs and budgets. Whether you start analog or go digital, consistent training and organization will make the biggest difference in how your livestream sounds each Sunday.
See some of our other related blog posts:
- No Sound? Quick Fixes for Audio Issues During Church Livestreams or Services
- How to Troubleshoot Audio Issues in the ATEM Mini
This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.